CostKit

Welding Cost Calculator

The expensive part of welding is rarely the filler wire — it is how long a 300 mm bead holds the station. This calculator separates arc time, arc-on ratio, fit-up, grinding, filler and shielding gas into lines you can argue about with a supplier.

¥— per part
Welder time
—
Machine time
—
Filler metal
—
Shielding gas
—

Arc — min · Station — min · Filler — g · Output — parts/hour

Range ±30%. Welding is position sensitive: the same bead length can take twice as long overhead as flat, and quotations rarely state the position. Wire changes, slag knocking and part flipping are folded into the arc-on ratio, so the result depends heavily on how the station is organised and how easy the part is to turn.

How the number is built

Formulas

bead length (m) = length mm × passes ÷ 1000
arc minutes     = bead length × 100 ÷ speed cm/min
station minutes = arc ÷ arc-on ratio + grinding + fit-up ÷ batch

labour  = station ÷ 60 × labour rate
machine = arc ÷ 60 × machine rate
filler  = bead length × g/m ÷ 1000 × price per kg
gas     = arc ÷ 60 × gas per hour
total   = labour + machine + filler + gas

Worked example

A 300 mm single-pass MIG bead, 3 minutes fit-up over a 100-part batch, 0.4 minutes grinding and a welder at 55 CNY/hour:

Arc time (0.3 m × 100 ÷ 35 cm/min)0.86 min
Station time (0.86 ÷ 0.55 + 0.4 + 0.03)1.99 min
Welder (1.99 ÷ 60 × 55)¥1.82
Machine (0.86 ÷ 60 × 25)¥0.36
Filler (105 g at 9 CNY/kg)¥0.95
Gas (0.86 ÷ 60 × 12)¥0.17
Total¥3.30 per part (about 30 parts/hour)

The same bead in TIG drops to 12 cm/min with a 0.45 arc-on ratio, pushing labour to roughly 6 CNY, and stainless filler plus more gas takes the part close to ¥9. TIG is expensive in labour, not material — which is why the thin-sheet stainless decision is really "does the saved labour pay for the laser's machine hour?"

Three lines suppliers pad

First, the arc-on ratio: quoting 0.30 instead of 0.55 doubles labour, and without line data it is hard to challenge — so ask for arc time and auxiliary time separately. Second, passes: 8 mm plate usually needs three, and a quote built on one pass under-charges while five over-charges; the groove detail settles it. Third, grinding: cosmetic parts cost three to five times a structural weld, yet quotes say only "includes grinding" — ask whether polishing is in.

Not included

FAQ

Why is stick welding more expensive than MIG?

Stick runs around 15 cm/min and every electrode has to be changed and deslagged, giving an arc-on ratio near 0.35 — less than half the station time is actual arcing. MIG feeds wire continuously and reaches 0.55, so the labour for the same bead is roughly halved. Filler price is not the driver.

How many passes do I need?

By thickness and groove: under 3 mm one pass, 3–6 mm two, 6–12 mm three to four, and thicker sections need a groove with multiple passes. Every added pass increases both filler and arc time linearly, so thick-plate welding cost is extremely sensitive to joint design.

When does laser welding pay?

Laser runs more than three times faster than MIG with little distortion and almost no grinding, but machine rates are high and fit-up must be tight (typically within 0.1 mm). Thin sheet (≤2 mm) at high volume is ideal; on thick plate or sloppy fit-up, rework eats the advantage.

Why is filler measured in grams?

Deposition scales with bead cross-section, so grams per metre already bakes in the groove size. Add 5–10% for spatter and wire stubs when purchasing, and remember that short runs waste more of each spool.