CostKit

Die Casting Defect Checklist

A trial report says "some porosity" and the supplier says "we'll polish it" — true for a bracket, fatal for a pressure-tight housing. This table orders 13 common die casting defects by what to check first, so you can tell a shot-profile or melt problem from work that needs the runner, the vents or the die itself changed.

Thirteen common defects

DefectCheck firstUsual root causeFixCost impact
Porosity / pinholes Shot sleeve fill and gate velocity Air entrapment, blocked vents, excess release agent, low sleeve fill Lower gate velocity, raise sleeve fill, add vents and overflows, use vacuum Settings first; pressure-tight parts need impregnation or a die change
Shrinkage porosity / sinks Wall thickness steps and hot spots Insufficient feeding, heavy section, high die temperature Feed through the gate, squeeze pin, thin the hot spot, cool the die Mostly settings; thinning means a die change
Cold shuts / misruns Die and metal temperature, shot speed Cold fill, restrictive runner, slow shot Raise die and metal temperature, faster shot, add end overflows Settings and trials; runner design means a die change
Slag / oxide inclusions Melting and transfer Poor degassing, dross carried over, oxide skin folded in Degas, filter, skim the melt, limit returns Yield loss; severe cases need runner changes
Cracks / hot tears Ejection timing and section transitions Ejected too early, sharp corners, uneven ejection Later ejection, add radii, balance ejection, control die temperature Die rework — radii and ejector layout
Distortion Cooling and ejection Uneven cooling, unbalanced ejection, poor straightening fixture Rework water lines, balance ejection, add a straightening fixture Die work plus straightening labour
Sticking / scoring Draft angle and die surface Low draft, aluminium pickup, too little release agent, hot die Polish, add draft, adjust spraying, apply a surface coating Die work plus polishing
Flash / burrs Clamp force and parting line Insufficient clamp, crushed parting line, high intensification Raise clamp force, repair the parting line, reduce intensification Settings or repair, plus deburring labour
Misrun (local short fill) Venting and gate area Blocked vents, small gate, low intensification pressure Clear vents, add overflows, raise pressure Minor die work
Blistering / blisters Die lubricant and venting Lubricant gas trapped, local overheating Change spraying, cut vents, cool the die Die work
Flow marks / water marks Fill speed and gate position Slow fill, cold die, wrong gate location Faster fill, hotter die, move the gate Cosmetic parts usually need a die change
Washout / soldering Die surface near the gate Sustained high gate velocity, local overheating, under-tempered die Slow down, rework the gate, stress relieve and nitride Die repair plus inserts
Leakage (failed pressure test) X-ray and pressure test first Entrapped air, shrinkage porosity, uneven walls Vacuum assist, squeeze pins, impregnation, runner changes Impregnation cost plus die changes

Troubleshooting order: melt, then die, then shot profile

As in injection molding, the floor order is usually reversed: chase the shot curve first, blame the die second, and look at the furnace last. In die casting the causal chain is shorter and harder: if the melt is gassy, no shot profile will produce a sound part. Rule out the melt, confirm venting and runner condition, and only then discuss shot speed and intensification pressure.

  1. Melt: was it degassed, was the dross skimmed, is the returns share too high, has the metal sat hot for too long (more oxidation, more gas pickup)? Inclusions, oxide skins and part of the subsurface porosity live here, and no shot setting fixes them.
  2. Die: are vent blocks and vent slots blocked, is the overflow volume sufficient, has the gate washed out, are cooling lines flowing, is the core soldering? Cold shuts, misruns, blisters and washout usually leave evidence here.
  3. Shot profile: slow shot speed, fast-shot position, gate velocity, intensification pressure, die temperature, spray cycle. Porosity, shrinkage, flow marks and flash mostly sit in this layer — and it is the layer people keep returning to, because it suppresses symptoms without changing where the air comes from.

Why venting and overflows beat knob-twiddling

Fill times in die casting are measured in tens of milliseconds, so the gas in the cavity has no time to escape — it can only be pushed somewhere planned. Overflow volume and vent placement therefore decide whether gas stays in the casting. A part that "cannot be tuned in" often has undersized overflows, vents sealed by lubricant, or a gate that fires metal straight at a core and curls air into the flow.

Three questions settle it: what is the total overflow volume, what is the vent depth, and when were the vents last cleaned? A supplier who cannot answer will struggle to hold lot-to-lot consistency. The machine tonnage and sleeve fill calculator also tells you the sleeve fill ratio — a low fill ratio means a higher proportion of air in the shot sleeve, and entrapment is then almost guaranteed.

Which defects require a die change

The test is the same as in molding: does the defect follow the runner, the vents, the ejectors or the wall thickness? If it does, tuning only hides the appearance until the next lot.

Conversely, flash, sticking, blistering and sink marks are tied to the current shot. Ask for clamp force, spray and die temperature adjustments before approving a rework quote — a die casting rework costs tens of thousands of CNY and buys two weeks of tuning.

Verifying internal soundness: X-ray, pressure test, sectioning

A cosmetically acceptable casting is not necessarily dense. Porosity and shrinkage can only be seen by radiography (X-ray), a pressure test (air decay or immersion), or destructive sectioning. Production lots usually sample the first two; structural and pressure-tight parts are tested 100%.

Write the acceptance criteria down, or every delivery reopens the same argument. Separate "not allowed" from "allowed up to", and state which face, what diameter, how many, and whether impregnation repair is permitted. Dimensional tolerances and machining allowances for castings follow ISO 8062-3; appearance and defect acceptance follow NADCA #401 (see references below).

Impregnation — forcing resin into connected porosity — is the usual rescue, priced per part and typically a few tenths to a few CNY. It seals connected leaks only, never shrinkage networks or broad sponge. Quoting impregnation upfront is cheaper than discovering it in rework.

How defects become money

There are three cost layers, and quotations usually price only the first:

Put all three into the yield and secondary-operation fields of the die casting cost calculator to get a real should-cost. Many "overpriced casting" arguments are really a supplier pricing these layers while the buyer compared alloy weight and machine time only.

Four things to demand when discussing defects

  1. Trial parameter records: slow shot speed, fast-shot position and speed, intensification pressure, die temperature, spray cycle. Undocumented adjustments cannot be reproduced.
  2. X-ray films or a pressure test report, not "we tapped it and it sounded fine". Key zones need a film or a number.
  3. An agreed defect standard: which face, what size, how many, whether impregnation is allowed — written into the drawing or a limit sample.
  4. Overflow and vent status: overflow volume, vent depth, cleaning frequency. These three decide lot-to-lot stability.

For cosmetic parts, define A, B, C and non-cosmetic surfaces at sampling stage. Different faces carry different acceptance limits; otherwise every lot renegotiates the same mark.

FAQ

Can higher intensification pressure cure porosity?

Only partly. It compacts shrinkage porosity, but entrained gas does not disappear — it is compressed and stays in the casting at a smaller size. The real cure is less entrapment: higher sleeve fill, lower gate velocity, adequate vents and overflows, and vacuum assist where needed.

Will impregnated parts leak again?

Not immediately, but thermal cycling or a later machining cut can reopen a path. For pressure-tight parts, treat impregnation as a rescue rather than a design target, and add hold time and temperature conditions to the pressure test.

Why do cold shuts appear when we move the die to another machine?

Tonnage and shot capacity differ, so the actual gate velocity changes. Re-calibrate fast-shot speed and intensification after a machine move, and re-check sleeve fill — change either and the fill pattern changes.

Why is deburring so expensive?

Flash distribution is irregular and most shops still deburr by hand. Parting-line design, insert fits and a trim tool can cut the cost, but they must be decided before the die is cut; afterwards you can only add labour.

Related: die casting cost calculator · tonnage and sleeve fill · die casting mould cost · process selection guide · glossary

References

  1. Product Standards for Die Castings NADCA · NADCA #401
  2. Castings — General dimensional and geometrical tolerances and machining allowances ISO · ISO 8062-3

Basis for the parameters above. Links go to the publisher or its search page; the standard text itself is sold by the publisher. Price references are public market ranges, not supplier quotations.